I had to give some thought to the phases we had gone through to come to this point. It starts the same way for each of us and most likely we get to the same place at the same time. You would think having a clear understanding of the process, we could avoid it. But it's such a natural part of human nature, there's truly not much we can do.
It starts in infancy. The parent perhaps starts with a minor hand slap to keep the baby from hurting themselves or someone (something) else. Or maybe the baby is putting something in their mouth that will choke them or make them sick and Mom or Dad pulls it away with a jerk. Whatever the action, the baby won't like it and so will begin hiding the offending behavior.
From there, we progress to those wonderful toddler years when the word "no" becomes the focal part of the vocabulary. By this time, our children have learned a lot about discipline, particularly that they don't like it one bit, and will do anything to avoid it. "Did you make this mess?" "No, Mommy. I didn't do it." Of course, Mommy already knows the answer to the question before she asks, so appropriate discipline is dished out anyway.
But we see by this stage that our child's thinking process has evolved. They now understand the connection between behavior and discipline. Occasionally, the story they weave to avoid the punishment works, so they begin working on developing those stories. But the reasoning remains the same....the child must avoid discipline at all costs.
With abstract thinking developing at a manic pace, we enter the school years. Avoidance of discipline is still a major issue, but our child is now discovering more about the world around them and is trying to make sense of it all. Imagination begins playing a major role in their development and they have more questions than answers. All that brain activity often leads to strange conversations like this one.
"Who made this mess?"
"I think a squirrel came in the window and made the mess, Mommy."
"Squirrels do not come in windows and make messes. I think you made this mess and I know you are going to clean it up."
"But, Mommy, I didn't make the mess. Maybe it was the little boy next door who came in and made the mess."
"Any why, pray tell, would the little boy next door come into your room and make such a mess."
"Because his mommy doesn't let him make messes in his room and he wanted to make a mess somewhere. So he sneaked over here when we weren't looking and went in my room and made a mess. Then when we weren't looking again he sneaked back out and went home. So now his room is all clean and mine is all dirty. That's what probably happened. Don't you think so, Mommy?"
"No, I don't think so. Clean up this room!"
This progression brought me to a strange conversation with this same child, now age 10, on a car ride just the other day. I'm not sure how we got on the subject of hair. It probably had something to do with my constant complaining that she doesn't brush hers enough.
"I've seen people with hair all the way down to their feet."
"Yes, honey. There was a singer when I was younger who had hair like that. I never could understand how she held her head up. That hair had to be very heavy."
"Oh, yeah. Well, I saw someone who had hair past their feet. It was dragging on the floor."
"I can't imagine why someone would want their hair dragging on the floor. You'd think it would get dirty, wouldn't you?"
"Well, it doesn't really. But the woman with the longest hair in the world had 15 feet of hair! And the man with the longest hair only has 2 feet of hair."
Long pause. How do I want to handle this situation. It's now obvious she's just trying to show she knows something I don't know, but I'm pretty sure she's wrong. However, in the one instance, I can't really prove she's wrong, so is this worth getting into an argument about.
"I'm pretty sure I could show you a man with more than 2 feet of hair. That's not really very much hair. In fact, your hair is probably 2 feet long and you know you've seen men out there with longer hair than you have." Ok, that one went well. She's not responding, but she's not arguing with me either.
"And, well, I think I'd have to see the woman with 15 feet of hair before I'd believe it."
Nothing. No argument, no defiance, no nothing. A quick change in the subject and we move on to something else.
Yes, the evolution of lying is an interesting one and we're still in the innocent years of lying. But if she can blurt it out now so easily, where am I going to be when she hits her teenage years just 3 short years from now.